Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) Rights in Collegiate Athletics: A Legal and Regulatory Overview
By Robert Steiner MS, M.Ed, JD
In recent years, the landscape of collegiate athletics has undergone significant transformation, particularly concerning the rights of student-athletes to profit from their name, image, and likeness (NIL).
This shift has been propelled by key legal and administrative developments, culminating in the NCAA's revised policies.
The Alston Case and Its Implications
The pivotal moment in this transition came with the Supreme Court case Alston v. NCAA, decided in June 2021. The case challenged the NCAA's restrictions on academic-related payments to student-athletes. The Supreme Court's ruling was a decisive blow to the NCAA's longstanding amateurism model, affirming that the organization could not limit such payments. This landmark decision was based on antitrust principles, with the Court finding that the NCAA's restrictions violated federal antitrust laws by unreasonably restraining trade.
The Alston decision set the stage for broader discussions on athlete compensation, highlighting the need for reforms beyond academic-related payments. The ruling was instrumental in catalyzing a broader reevaluation of how collegiate athletes can be compensated, particularly regarding NIL rights.
NCAA's Response and Policy Changes
In response to the Alston ruling and mounting pressure from member institutions, the NCAA made significant changes to its policies. Historically, the NCAA had stringent rules prohibiting athletes from receiving compensation related to their NIL, which was seen as a critical component of its amateurism model. However, with the changing legal landscape and increased scrutiny, the NCAA updated its regulations to allow athletes to profit from their NIL.
On July 1, 2021, the NCAA temporarily suspended its restrictions on athletes earning money from endorsements, social media, and other commercial activities. This move was seen as a necessary adaptation to the evolving legal and economic environment surrounding collegiate sports.
Further regulatory refinements were introduced in January 2023. The NCAA adopted additional NIL rules that mandated the voluntary registration of NIL service providers, imposed disclosure requirements for student-athletes, standardized NIL contracts, and introduced educational resources for athletes navigating these new opportunities. These measures aimed to create a more structured and transparent framework for NIL dealings, balancing the interests of athletes, universities, and other stakeholders.
Legal Challenges and Developments
Despite these advancements, the NCAA's approach to NIL has faced legal challenges. Notably, a federal judge granted a preliminary injunction on February 23, 2023, in the cases of Tennessee and Virginia v. NCAA, which challenged the NCAA's NIL recruiting restrictions. This injunction effectively banned the NCAA's limitations on how institutions, booster clubs, and collectives could interact with prospective athletes regarding NIL offers.
This legal development underscored the ongoing tension between regulatory bodies and the evolving expectations around athlete compensation. It also highlighted the challenges in crafting policies that address both competitive fairness and the commercial realities of modern collegiate sports.
Conclusion
The evolution of NIL rights in collegiate athletics marks a significant departure from traditional amateurism principles. The combination of legal challenges, such as the Alston case, and subsequent regulatory changes by the NCAA reflect a broader recognition of the value that student-athletes bring to collegiate sports. As the landscape continues to evolve, ongoing legal and administrative developments will likely shape the future of athlete compensation, ensuring that the interests of all parties involved are considered in this new era of collegiate athletics.
For further information or to discuss any legal matters, please contact Attorney Robert Steiner at (205) 826-4421 or via email at robert@steinerfirm.com. Whether you have questions about this article or need personalized legal advice, he is available to assist you.
 Rights in Collegiate Athletics: A Legal and Regulatory Overview){kind=link}